Players Who Played for Hawthorn and St Kilda

20 players have played senior AFL for both Hawthorn and St Kilda since 1990, led by Ben McEvoy (161 games for Hawthorn, 91 for St Kilda). Here is every one, with games and seasons at each club.

Most clubs

First clubSecond club

20 players have played senior AFL for both Hawthorn and St Kilda since 1990, led by Ben McEvoy (161 games for Hawthorn, 91 for St Kilda).

1.Ben McEvoy252 games
- Hawthorn 161 · 2014–2022
- St Kilda 91 · 2008–2013
2.Peter Everitt291 games
- Hawthorn 72 · 2003–2006
- St Kilda 180 · 1993–2002
- Sydney 39 · 2007–2008
3.Bradley Hill300 games
- Hawthorn 95 · 2012–2016
- St Kilda 151 · 2020–2026
- Fremantle 54 · 2017–2019
4.Joel Smith221 games
- Hawthorn 163 · 1999–2007
- St Kilda 58 · 1995–1997
5.Brent Guerra255 games
- Hawthorn 159 · 2006–2013
- St Kilda 31 · 2004–2005
- Port Adelaide 65 · 2000–2003
6.Josh Battle171 games
- Hawthorn 48 · 2025–2026
- St Kilda 123 · 2017–2024
7.Shane Savage165 games
- Hawthorn 56 · 2009, 2011–2013
- St Kilda 109 · 2014–2020
8.Dean Anderson129 games
- Hawthorn 62 · 1990–1992
- St Kilda 67 · 1993–1996
9.Matthew Young118 games
- Hawthorn 21 · 1994–1995
- St Kilda 97 · 1996–2001
10.James Frawley241 games
- Hawthorn 100 · 2015–2020
- St Kilda 2 · 2021
- Melbourne 139 · 2007–2014
11.Zac Dawson166 games
- Hawthorn 14 · 2005–2006
- St Kilda 63 · 2009–2011
- Fremantle 89 · 2012–2017
12.Russell Morris76 games
- Hawthorn 10 · 1990
- St Kilda 66 · 1991–1994
13.Chris Wittman44 games
- Hawthorn 35 · 1990–1992
- St Kilda 9 · 1993
14.Glenn Nugent35 games
- Hawthorn 24 · 1990–1994
- St Kilda 11 · 1995
15.Sean Ralphsmith33 games
- Hawthorn 3 · 1990
- St Kilda 30 · 1991–1994
16.Tim Allen34 games
- Hawthorn 11 · 1993–1994
- St Kilda 22 · 1991–1992
- Geelong 1 · 1995
17.Darren Minchington32 games
- Hawthorn 4 · 2020
- St Kilda 28 · 2013–2017
18.Ricky Nixon26 games
- Hawthorn 8 · 1992–1993
- St Kilda 18 · 1990–1991
19.Lawrence Bingham23 games
- Hawthorn 1 · 1990
- St Kilda 22 · 1992–1993
20.Nick Stone20 games
- Hawthorn 17 · 2002–2003
- St Kilda 3 · 2004–2005

Senior games from 1990 on only. Players whose careers began earlier show their games since 1990.

At a glance

20 players have played senior AFL for both Hawthorn and St Kilda since 1990, led by Ben McEvoy (161 games for Hawthorn, 91 for St Kilda).
12 went from Hawthorn to St Kilda, and eight the other way.
Six of the 20 also played for at least one other club.
The most recent of them to play for either club: Bradley Hill and Josh Battle, in 2026.
That ranks 3 of the 171 club pairings by shared players since 1990.

Checked 21 October 2026 · data as of 15 September 2026

Every player who played for both

20 players, most games for the two clubs first. Games and seasons are from 1990 on.
Player	Hawthorn	St Kilda	Other clubs	Total
Ben McEvoy	161 (2014–2022)	91 (2008–2013)	–	252
Peter Everitt	72 (2003–2006)	180 (1993–2002)	Sydney 39	291
Bradley Hill	95 (2012–2016)	151 (2020–2026)	Fremantle 54	300
Joel Smith	163 (1999–2007)	58 (1995–1997)	–	221
Brent Guerra	159 (2006–2013)	31 (2004–2005)	Port Adelaide 65	255
Josh Battle	48 (2025–2026)	123 (2017–2024)	–	171
Shane Savage	56 (2009, 2011–2013)	109 (2014–2020)	–	165
Dean Anderson^†	62 (1990–1992)	67 (1993–1996)	–	129
Matthew Young	21 (1994–1995)	97 (1996–2001)	–	118
James Frawley	100 (2015–2020)	2 (2021)	Melbourne 139	241
Zac Dawson	14 (2005–2006)	63 (2009–2011)	Fremantle 89	166
Russell Morris^†	10 (1990)	66 (1991–1994)	–	76
Chris Wittman^†	35 (1990–1992)	9 (1993)	–	44
Glenn Nugent	24 (1990–1994)	11 (1995)	–	35
Sean Ralphsmith^†	3 (1990)	30 (1991–1994)	–	33
Tim Allen	11 (1993–1994)	22 (1991–1992)	Geelong 1	34
Darren Minchington	4 (2020)	28 (2013–2017)	–	32
Ricky Nixon^†	8 (1992–1993)	18 (1990–1991)	–	26
Lawrence Bingham^†	1 (1990)	22 (1992–1993)	–	23
Nick Stone	17 (2002–2003)	3 (2004–2005)	–	20

† Career began before 1990: earlier games are not counted.

Quick answers

20 players have played senior AFL for both Hawthorn and St Kilda since 1990, led by Ben McEvoy (161 games for Hawthorn, 91 for St Kilda). See the list→
Of the players who played for both, Joel Smith played the most games for Hawthorn: 163. See the list→
Of the players who played for both, Peter Everitt played the most games for St Kilda: 180. See the list→
12 of them played for Hawthorn first and eight played for St Kilda first. See the list→
Six of the 20 also played for a third club. See the list→
291 players have played senior AFL for Hawthorn since 1990, and 163 of them also played for another club. Open the tool→
336 players have played senior AFL for St Kilda since 1990, and 182 of them also played for another club. Open the tool→
Hawthorn shares the most players with St Kilda: 20. See them→
St Kilda shares the most players with Hawthorn: 20. See them→
Did Ben McEvoy play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 161 games for Hawthorn (2014–2022) and 91 for St Kilda (2008–2013). See the list→
Did Peter Everitt play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 72 games for Hawthorn (2003–2006) and 180 for St Kilda (1993–2002). See the list→
Did Bradley Hill play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 95 games for Hawthorn (2012–2016) and 151 for St Kilda (2020–2026). See the list→
Did Joel Smith play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 163 games for Hawthorn (1999–2007) and 58 for St Kilda (1995–1997). See the list→
Did Brent Guerra play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 159 games for Hawthorn (2006–2013) and 31 for St Kilda (2004–2005). See the list→
Did Josh Battle play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 48 games for Hawthorn (2025–2026) and 123 for St Kilda (2017–2024). See the list→
Did Shane Savage play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 56 games for Hawthorn (2009, 2011–2013) and 109 for St Kilda (2014–2020). See the list→
Did Dean Anderson play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 62 games for Hawthorn (1990–1992) and 67 for St Kilda (1993–1996). See the list→
Did Matthew Young play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 21 games for Hawthorn (1994–1995) and 97 for St Kilda (1996–2001). See the list→
Did James Frawley play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 100 games for Hawthorn (2015–2020) and 2 for St Kilda (2021). See the list→
Did Zac Dawson play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 14 games for Hawthorn (2005–2006) and 63 for St Kilda (2009–2011). See the list→
Did Russell Morris play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 10 games for Hawthorn (1990) and 66 for St Kilda (1991–1994). See the list→
Did Chris Wittman play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 35 games for Hawthorn (1990–1992) and 9 for St Kilda (1993). See the list→
Did Glenn Nugent play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 24 games for Hawthorn (1990–1994) and 11 for St Kilda (1995). See the list→
Did Sean Ralphsmith play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 3 games for Hawthorn (1990) and 30 for St Kilda (1991–1994). See the list→
Did Tim Allen play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 11 games for Hawthorn (1993–1994) and 22 for St Kilda (1991–1992). See the list→
Did Darren Minchington play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 4 games for Hawthorn (2020) and 28 for St Kilda (2013–2017). See the list→
Did Ricky Nixon play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 8 games for Hawthorn (1992–1993) and 18 for St Kilda (1990–1991). See the list→
Did Lawrence Bingham play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 1 game for Hawthorn (1990) and 22 for St Kilda (1992–1993). See the list→
Did Nick Stone play for Hawthorn and St Kilda? Yes: 17 games for Hawthorn (2002–2003) and 3 for St Kilda (2004–2005). See the list→

Hawthorn shares the most with

St Kilda shares the most with

All club pairings and the most-clubs list →

Common questions

How many players have played for both Hawthorn and St Kilda?

20 players have played senior AFL for both Hawthorn and St Kilda since 1990, led by Ben McEvoy (161 games for Hawthorn, 91 for St Kilda).

What counts as playing for a club?

At least one senior AFL game for that club in 1990 or later. Games before 1990 are not counted, so a career that began in the 1980s shows only its games since 1990.

How up to date is it?

The data is as of 15 September 2026. Games and clubs are compiled from public records: AFL Tables season statistics and Wikipedia.

Sources

Season player statistics, 1990 to 2026, from AFL Tables (afltables.com).
Club and honour records from Wikipedia.
Data as of 15 September 2026. Facts compiled from public records; no text is copied from either source.

Test yourself

Siren Rush pairs a club with a clue, like a player who also played for another club. Name one before the siren: any senior player since 1990 counts, and the fewer people who name your pick, the more it scores.

Play Siren Rush Or draft today’s side